Last updated on August 3rd, 2024 at 08:59 am
Did you know that although eyewitness testimony has been regarded as one of the most effective types of evidence in criminal court, it’s still not as reliable as it seems? According to a study by The Innocence Project, in 70% of Michigan criminal registry cases, an eyewitness falsely accused the defendant of a crime they did not commit. Believe it or not, there are instances when you can’t fully trust your own eyes, especially when it comes to recalling events during eyewitness testimony. It’s heartbreaking to know that 71% of the 358 individuals convicted through eyewitnesses have been misidentified and had served an average of 14 years in jail. If you are being accused of a crime and you’re looking to prove your innocence and fight wrongful eyewitness testimony, read on. Here are some factors that can affect the credibility of eyewitness testimony:
Table of Contents
Memory Distortion
Memory distortion is a common phenomenon that can affect the reliability of eyewitness testimony. When you witness an event, your brain encodes and stores the information in your memory but during the retrieval process, your memory can be influenced by plenty of factors, leading to distortions.
- The passage of time. As time goes by, your memory of an event can fade or become altered. Details may be lost or replaced with false information, making it difficult to accurately recall what you saw.
- The presence of post-event information. When you’re exposed to new information about an event after you witness it, it can contaminate your memory. This can occur through conversations with others, media reports, or even your thoughts and beliefs. The new information can merge with your original memory, ending up with inaccuracies in your testimony.
- Emotions can also impact memory distortion. High levels of stress or emotional arousal during an event can impair your ability to encode and retrieve accurate information. Your memory may become fragmented or distorted, making it a challenge to provide reliable testimony.
Leading Questions
The influence of leading questions is also another thing that could impact the reliability of eyewitness testimony. When you’re asked questions that are phrased in a suggestive or leading manner, it can distort your memory and affect the accuracy of your recollection. For instance, if someone asks you, ‘Did you see the blue car hit the red car?’ it suggests that there was indeed a blue car involved in the accident, even if you didn’t see it. This can lead you to falsely remember seeing a blue car when in reality there may not have been one. The power of suggestion in leading questions is strong, as it can create a false memory that aligns with the questioner’s assumptions or expectations. The wording of the question itself can also influence your response. Subtle changes in phrasing, such as using words like ‘smashed’ instead of ‘hit,’ can guide you to give different answers. Be cautious when providing eyewitness testimony, especially when asked by leading questions.
External Influences
Be mindful of the external influences that greatly affect the accuracy of your memory and can lead to false or distorted testimony when providing eyewitness testimony.
- The presence of a weapon. Research has shown that the presence of a weapon during a crime can draw your attention and focus away from other details, causing you to have a less accurate memory of the event.
- The use of stress-inducing factors during the event. High levels of stress can impair your ability to encode and retrieve memories accurately, leading to a less reliable testimony.
- The presence of co-witnesses can also impact your recollection. Hearing others’ accounts of the event can lead to memory contamination, where you incorporate their details into your memory, making your testimony inaccurate.
Stress and Anxiety
When you’re under extreme stress, your ability to accurately recall details of an event can be compromised. Research has shown that stress can impair your memory, making it more difficult to remember specific details or accurately identify individuals involved in a crime or incident. There is plenty of reasons for this to happen, we’ve listed it down for you below:
- Stress triggers the release of stress hormones, such as cortisol, which can interfere with the functioning of the hippocampus – the part of the brain responsible for memory formation and retrieval. This can result in difficulties in encoding and retrieving information, causing gaps or inaccuracies in your recollection of events.
- High levels of anxiety can also affect your attention and perception. When you’re anxious, your focus may narrow, and you may become more prone to selective attention, only noticing certain aspects of the event while ignoring others, resulting in biased or incomplete information being stored in your memory.
- Stress and anxiety can influence how you interpret and perceive information in the first place. When you’re in a heightened emotional state, your perception can be distorted, leading to memory errors or false memories. This can be particularly problematic when identifying a suspect from a lineup, as your heightened anxiety may lead to a false identification.
Cross-Racial Identification
High levels of stress and anxiety can adversely affect the accuracy of your eyewitness identification, particularly in cases of cross-racial identification. Research has shown that people tend to have more difficulty recognizing faces of individuals from a different racial or ethnic background than their own, a phenomenon, known as the cross-race effect or own-race bias. One possible explanation for this effect is that individuals have more experience and exposure to faces that are similar to their own racial or ethnic group. As a result, they become more adept at distinguishing and remembering those faces. When faced with individuals from a different racial or ethnic background, this familiarity and expertise may not be as strong, leading to decreased accuracy in identification.
Stereotypes and biases can also come into play during cross-racial identification. Research has shown that people tend to rely on racial stereotypes when identifying individuals from a different racial group. These biases can influence the encoding and retrieval processes of memory, leading to false identifications or misinterpretations of events. Given these challenges, law enforcement officials, legal professionals, and jurors must be aware of these factors and take them into account when evaluating eyewitness accounts. Implementing measures to reduce bias, such as using unbiased lineup procedures, can help mitigate the influence of cross-racial identification on the accuracy of eyewitness testimony.
Related Articles:
The Role of Evidence in Winning Motorcycle Accident Lawsuits
Steps to Filing a Lawsuit Against Negligent Manufacturers
Conclusion
There are plenty of factors that can greatly impact the reliability of eyewitness testimony. Memories are prone to distortion over time, and leading questions can manipulate the recollection of events. The addition of stress and anxiety can impair a person’s ability to recall details accurately. The phenomenon called cross-racial identification can introduce biases and affect the reliability of eyewitness testimony. These factors should be considered when evaluating the credibility of eyewitness accounts.
